Jobs and Careers
HE

Customer Service, Supervisor - Diploma

Herff Jones
Indianapolis, United Statesfull_timeVerifiedPosted 15 Feb 2026
💰 $76,000/yr($52,000/yr$76,000/yr)

About the role

THE MOST TRUSTED NAME IN CELEBRATING STUDENT MILESTONES – HERFF JONES
Herff Jones is the leading provider of graduation and educational products and services designed to inspire achievement and create memorable experiences for students. Herff Jones' products include class rings and jewelry, caps and gowns, frames, announcements, and Greek accessories as well as motivation and recognition programs. Since 1920, our team has worked alongside students, faculty, and staff on campuses nationwide to help build a stronger community and celebrate student milestones. Our continued success relies on hiring extraordinary talent, with a passion for making a difference and eagerness to roll up the sleeves, to help us write the story of our next 100 years.


The Herff Jones Diploma division is looking for a Customer Service Supervisor to join our Diploma Customer Service team. This position will assist the strategy and execution of the customer support functions in our Indianapolis IN plant.

This position is responsible for ensuring that customer needs are being met through phone, e-mail, web, and future channels as needed. The Supervisor of the Diploma Customer Service Team will play an integral role in maintaining outstanding employee service levels with customers and sales partners, improve quality of service, maintain professional and technical knowledge while upholding Herff Jones corporate values. In all activities, the Diploma Customer Service Supervisor will represent Herff Jones in a positive and professional manner.

What we want you to accomplish:

In your first 30 days:
▪ Understand Customer Service process flows, pricing, key policies & procedures.
▪ Understand Specialty accounts, ZenDesk, and telephony systems.
▪ Review daily reporting and attend GEMBA daily to understand metrics.
▪ Work with Trainer to learn Customer Service processes as quickly as possible.
In your first 60 days:
• Build a working relationship across the Diploma CS and Manufacturing Teams.
• Lead the Diploma Customer Service Team and work closely with the Order Entry Supervisor to ensure that the CS, Order Entry and Data Formatting teams meet daily metrics and goals.
• Review Corrective Actions and Respond to Corrective Actions.
• Assist with training/interviewing for new hires.
In your first 90 days and beyond:
• Own daily management of Channel Service levels: phone, tickets, chat, etc. Attend GEMBA regularly (at least 2x/week).
• Own coordination with offshore Level 1 team to ensure warm handoffs of calls & tickets to maintain – and preferably elevate - customer satisfaction.
• Review and develop SOPs for the Customer Service Teams as appropriate.
• Review updates to training documents and Standard operating procedures (SOPs) as changes occur; ensure that updates are made timely by training team.
• Daily reinforce positive work environment; own & drive morale within the team.
• Assess each employee on knowledge of processes, data, and tools; coach as needed.
• Coach team members in soft skills required for success, such as strong work ethic, empathy for customers, appropriate messaging and tone.
• Own & drive quality in all aspects of the team’s work: “If we have time to do it wrong, we have time to do it right”.
• Seek opportunities to improve process flows, policies, and/ or procedures.
• Build & maintain a strong working relationship across the Diploma CS and Manufacturing Teams.
• Lead the Diploma Customer Service Team and work closely with the Order Entry Supervisor to ensure that the CS, Order Entry and Data Formatting teams meet daily metrics and goals.
• Contribute to & review Corrective Actions/ Preventive Actions.
• Assist with training/interviewing for new hires.
Here's How You’ll Make an Impact:
The Customer Service Supervisor will consistently model excellent behaviors and provide direction for the team. Know that customer service is just as important as the physical quality of each diploma that is crafted in our Indianapolis plant: this leader will always drive toward improving the Customer Experience.

What you’ll be doing daily:
• Supervise team members assigned to your group.
• Work across the Customer Service, Order Entry and Data Formatting Teams to meet or exceed daily goals.
• Develop relationships with Order Entry, Namelist/ data formatting, & manufacturing team members to ensure that orders are moving forward once they have left Customer Service.
• Daily+, monitor dashboards in Zendesk ticketing system and telephony platform to ensure that ALL incoming communications are handled within “24 & 2”: meaningful response within 24 hours and no more than 2 emails back & forth, then phone/ chat.
• Support the Department manager in communicati

Apply for this role

Generate a tailored application kit with a matched cover letter, interview prep, and CV highlights — in under 60 seconds.

Apply Now →Generate Application Kit

Free account required — sign up in 30s

Company

Herff Jones

View company profile →