Jobs and Careers
PL
Senior Claims Representative, Casualty
Plymouth Rock AssuranceUnited Statesfull_timeVerifiedPosted 17 Nov 2025
💰 $76,000/yr($58,000/yr – $76,000/yr)
About the role
The Casualty Claim Representative will be responsible for the handling of First- and Third-Party Bodily Injury and Physical Damage claims in a Personal Lines /Commercial environment for the Plymouth Rock Operation. The candidate must have the skills listed below and be able to perform the following duties:
RESPONSIBILITIES
- Initiate prompt contact of all insureds/claimants/witnesses on all new claim assignments to conduct thorough coverage and liability/injury investigations. These investigations might require the representatives take in depth recorded statements to investigate coverage and liability/injury claims.
- Analyze, review and interpret policies to assess coverage and liability. Provide advice to Excess and Primary coverage issues.
- Willing to conduct investigations, interviews with insureds, witnesses and claimants while maintaining a pending of represented claimant cases.
- Manage and direct outside vendors (Field/Counsel/Surveillance, Etc..) to determine what investigation is necessary and give them direction to bring a claim to conclusion. Ensure only necessary work is completed.
- Investigate cases timely so that reserves are established and maintained at proper levels. Revise reserves timely based on developments in the course of the claim.
- Investigate the validity of bodily injury claims being presented by individual insureds/claimants or attorneys representing insureds/claimants. Be aware of certain “Red Flags” to identify potential fraudulent claims. Refer to SIU for investigation timely.
- Have advanced skills in coverage, investigation, litigation/ legal issues, negotiations, evaluations, medical terminology, and subrogation. Handle more complex claims to include coverage issues, UM/UIM, etc.. Also, must have prior litigation handling.
- Recognize and investigate subrogation potential.
- Negotiate both 1st and 3rd party claims directly with injured parties or their attorneys.
- Exercises proper judgment and decision making to analyze exposure, determine the proper course of action and make recommendations for final resolution.
- Attend litigation proceedings to either represent the company or participate in arbitrations/depositions/settlement conferences/ mediations/ trials.
- Attend all internal and external training events as required.
- Participate in proactive team activities to achieve departmental and company objectives. May be asked to participate in special projects, committees or assignments from management.
- Possess strong organizational skills, able to demonstrate time management, has the ability to prioritize multiple tasks/duties, and be proficient in the utilization of all claims systems, Excel, Word and social media search engines.
- Have strong communication skills both verbal and written. Provide strong customer service. Prepare case summary for significant reserve increase and/or trial alerts. Participate in roundtables.
- Capable of working independently without close supervision, high level of self motivation, effectively manage workload while maintaining diary and focus on claims quality.
- Ability to handle multiple responsibilities and be adept at conflict resolution while working in a team environment. Work well under pressure. Able to think strategically, solve problems, set priorities, make the necessary decisions to resolve complex/regular issues/claims.
- Possess knowledge of and adherence to State(s) laws and regulatory claim handling guidelines and statutory regulations.
- Adhere to departmental internal control requirements. Comply with Plymouth Rock’s standards, best practices and ethical guidelines, adhere to Plymouth Rock’s culture
QUALIFICATIONS
- A bachelor's degree (B.A.) from an accredited four year college or university.
- 3 - 5 years’ experience handling liability and/or Personal Injury Protection claims.
- 1 year of experience handling bodily injury or casualty claims.
- Some litigation experience and knowledge of the New Jersey court system is preferred.
- Knowledge of PA, CT or NY claims handling would be beneficial.
- Currently holds and/or can readily obtain an out of State License(s) (i.e. - CT, Delaware, Florida, etc.) is preferred
SALARY RANGE
The pay range for this position is $58,000 to $76,000 annually. Actual compensation will vary bas
Apply for this role
Generate a tailored application kit with a matched cover letter, interview prep, and CV highlights — in under 60 seconds.
Apply Now →Generate Application KitFree account required — sign up in 30s