Jobs and Careers

Subrogation Supervisor

United StatesRemotefull_timeVerifiedPosted 28 Apr 2026

About the role

Safepoint MGA, LLC is a Property and Casualty insurance carrier headquartered in Tampa, FL. Position will be based in Florida.

Job Summary
The Subrogation Supervisor manages a team of subrogation examiners and oversees claims with subrogation potential and possible recovery. The supervisor ensures that the new claims with subrogation possibilities are timely reviewed by the subrogation examiners to ensure that evidence is maintained and that the claim is being properly investigated from a subrogation perspective. Claims that can be pursued are to be overseen by the supervisor and the supervisor will maintain a log on these claims. The supervisor will oversee the subrogation recoveries and will ensure that the subrogation recovery is documented in the claim files.

Duties and responsibilities

Provide new claim reports to the subrogation examiners for the preceding week’s claims to determine if subrogation possibilities exist.
Evaluate the subrogation possibility of a claim and its potential for recovery.
Maintain a log of claims with subrogation potential and supervises the subrogation examiners on these claims to determine if subrogation is to be pursued.
Maintain log on subrogation claims that are being pursued and any subrogation claims that are in litigation.
Supervise examiners on subrogation demand letters.
Supervise negotiated settlements on subrogation claims in excess of subrogation examiners authority and within supervisor’s authority.
Make recommendations to upper management if attorney is needed to pursue subrogation.
Document the claim files as to the amount of the recovery and any expenses associated with the subrogation claim.

Essential Functions

Supervise subrogation examiners to ensure the review of new claims with subrogation potential.
Ability to think critically and review claims where subrogation possibilities may exist and give guidance on further investigation that may be needed.
Review subrogation referrals from claim examiners, adjusters and claims management.
Provide direction on subrogation pursuits.
Analyze any offers made from adverse party. Provide authority to subrogation examiners if claim is to be negotiated.
Execute releases from adverse parties.
Participate in the hiring, coaching, and development of subrogation examiners.
Provide training to staff examiners and adjusters on subrogation claims.
Ability to effectively communicate verbally and in writing

Qualifications

Required: At least 5 years of claim adjusting experience, including subrogation experience.
Previous leadership experience and subrogation supervision preferred.
Required: Florida Adjuster’s License (6-20)
Bachelor’s Degree preferred. A combination of education and significant directly related experience may be considered in lieu of degree.
Proficiency with Microsoft Office products required.
Results driven with strong team management, problem solving and analytical skills.
English and Spanish speaking and writing skills preferred.

Working conditions
This position is performed remotely from a home office environment. This requires the use of standard office equipment, including computers and audio devices. Employees must maintain a reliable high-speed, password protected internet connection and a quiet, professional workspace that allows for uninterrupted work during scheduled hours. The position also requires the ability to safeguard and maintain confidentiality and security of sensitive information while working remotely.

Physical requirements
While performing the duties of this job, the employee is regularly required to talk or hear. The employee frequently is required to sit, stand; walk; use hands and fingers to handle or feel; and reach with hands and arms.

Compensation and Benefits
We recognize that talented professionals are attracted to companies that provide a great place to work, combined with a comprehensive and competitive pay and benefits package, along with opportunities for personal growth and job advancement. For this reason we are pleased to provide: